banner small

Real concern over packaging recycling targets

Real concern over packaging recycling targets

Packaging manufacturers have expressed real concern about the amount they may have to pay to meet higher packaging recycling targets proposed for 2013-17, as a consultation on the proposals closed today (February 10).

However, local authorities have welcomed the prosposals as a means for attracting more investment in council services.

In December 2011, Defra launched an eight-weekconsultation on proposals to introduce higher packaging recycling targets for steel, aluminium and plastics from 2013-17 and introduce a split target for glass. It also proposed to keep targets for wood and paper the same (see letsrecycle.com story).

But, according to a response submitted by the Packaging Federation, the UK is far from having the collection and sorting infrastructure in place to meetthese challenging targets,thereby potentially placing a huge cost burden on business.

The government is proposing to raise packaging recycling targets for steel, aluminium and plastics and split the target for glass
The government is proposing to raise packaging recycling targets for steel, aluminium and plastics and split the target for glass

Packaging Federation chief executive Dick Searle said Our industry has a real concern about the potential cost impact upon it. We operate in a highly competitive and adversarial supply chain in which we, regrettably, are the weakest link.

If PRN prices are driven high by targets for which the infrastructure is not in place, there is a real danger that a disproportionate share of the costs (and far higher than the official 9%) will fall on our industry.

The Federation also claims that the assumption that ever-increasing recycling rates are automatically the right environmental solution, does not stand up to rigorous scientific scrutiny. And, the Federation fears that the pursuit of higher targets is already damaging the quality of materials available for recycling and the imposition of higher targets will exacerbate this problem.

The Federation is also concerned that higher targets will further distort competition between obligated producers andsmall companies,such as corner shops, which are currently not obligated to pay towards packaging recycling.

Dick Searle, Packaging Federation
Dick Searle, Packaging Federation

If PRN prices are driven high by targets for which the infrastructure is not in place, there is a real danger that a disproportionate share of the costs (and far higher than the official 9%) will fall on our industry

Dick Searle, Packaging Federation

INCPEN

This concern over ‘obligated tonnage’ is shared by INCPEN which represents companies from throughout the packaging supply chain.

In its consultation response, INCPEN says there needs to be more investment in collection, sorting and cleaning infrastructure and that measures to include more non-obligated companies should be explored to close the ‘obligated tonnage gap’.

INCPEN agrees that the governments preferred option is the best approach but says this is not the case for steel and plastics.

Plastics

For plastics, INCPEN says industry believes the proposed 42% national plastics packaging recycling target (57% target for obligated companies) is too high. It says that countries that have been recycling plastics for much longer and have better infrastructure in the UK are well below this such as Austria (35% in 2008), Belgium (39%) and Sweden (37%).

INCPEN adds that an increasing amount of plastics are also being used to generate energy.

Steel

On the issue of steel, meanwhile, INCPEN says the industry wants a 2% year-on-year increase in the steel target, as opposed to the 1% proposed by the government. This is to encourage steel reprocessors to become accredited to issue PRNs, following a big fall-off in the number of companies registered (see letsrecycle.com story).

INCPENs consultation response explains: The steel industry believes a 2% year-on-year target is necessary to bring some value to PRNs and encourage companies to register to issue steel PRNS which has dropped from more than 70 in 2010 to 33 this year.

Local authorities

Despite concerns from producers, local authorites have generally welcomed the proposals, provided there is no increased costs for councils.

Local authorites are concerned that even though around half of packaging waste comes from households and is handled by waste authorities, they currently receive no direct financial assistance from producers who profit by its use, but only indirect support through the PRN system.

In its consultation response, London Councils- which represents London’s 33 local authoriites -said it hoped the proposed targets would see the value of PRNs rise and also see more producers and retailers investing directly in council collections and recycling infrastructure in order to meet them.

It said: “London Councils supports the higher targets and sees this as an opportunity for producers and reprocesors to work directly with waste authorities to provide the infrastructure required to meet the targets.”

It added: “London Councils is keen to explore the potential in London for pilots with a major retailer along the lines of the M&S work in Somerset whereby the retailer directly funds enhances recovery of recyclable materials and reuses a proportion of the materials collected.”

Register for free to comment

Subscribe to receive our newsletters and to leave comments.

The Blog Box

Back to top

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest waste and recycling news straight to your inbox.

Subscribe
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.