banner small

Questions raised over 2004 packaging reprocessing figures

Plastic bottle recycling organisation Recoup is to question figures that show a leap in plastic bottle recycling in the last three months of 2004 at a meeting with industry stakeholders later this month.

The data on how much packaging waste was recovered during 2004 shows a “big jump” in the amount of plastic packaging waste recycled from the third to the fourth quarters of the year.

During the first three quarters of 2004, plastic packaging reprocessing averaged out at just over 82,000 tonnes in each quarter. In the last quarter of 2004, Defra stated that over 99,400 tonnes of plastic packaging waste was recycled.


”The key thing for the PRN market is to be transparent and timely in the data.“
– Andrew Simmons, Recoup

Recoup chief executive Andrew Simmons told letsrecycle.com that he believed this increase “cannot be fully explained”. And, he said the fact that Christmas period effectively shortened the fourth quarter made the increase even harder to understand.

The jump in plastics reprocessing coincided with a significant increase in the price of PRNs – packaging waste reprocessing notes – the evidence packaging producers buy from accredited reprocessors to prove their Packaging Directive obligations have been carried out.

Mr Simmons said: “There was a big jump in plastic tonnages in the final quarter results. Some of this will be from new registrations from exporters, but this cannot explain all of that increase. If you look at the first three quarters of declared tonnages, it is in the mid-80,000 tonnes area, the final quarter is significantly higher in the tonnage reported.”

Households
There has been “good growth” in the collection of plastic bottles from households, Mr Simmons said, adding that councils are very interested in how they can add plastic bottle collections to their existing services. But neither this – nor the Recycle Now Christmas recycling campaign – explained the sudden growth in fourth quarter reprocessing, he said.

One strong possibility was that material reprocessed or exported earlier in the year was not reported until the last quarter of 2004. If this was the case, Mr Simmons said it would not be favourable for the PRN market.

“The key thing for the PRN market is to be transparent and timely in the data. What is critical is to get good, timely data from the Environment Agency to see if we are on track,” he said.

Market
The market for PRNs – the tradeable permits issued by packaging waste reprocessors against material they have recycled – is already being affected by fraud found in the plastics sector in 2003.

Prices for plastics PRNs have sky-rocketed in recent months (see PRN price archive) because the market realised that that the reprocessing performance in 2004 would not meet government-set targets for producers to recycle their obligation of plastics packaging waste. Early September 2004 saw plastics PRNs selling for between 11 and 13 per tonne, but prices rose to 40 per tonne in December.

The prospect that some form of fraud still remains in the plastics sector will not help the UK in meeting its recycling requirements set by the European Packaging Directive for 2008. Investment from PRN revenue is supposed to boost the recycling capacity of the UK in order to meet the terms of the Directive, but fraudulent PRNs mean the loss of the much-needed investment and excessive costs for packaging producers.

Related links:

Defra: packaging reprocessing data

letsrecycle.com: PRNs and PRN prices

Protocol
A new protocol, similar to the protocol being finalised among wood packaging waste reprocessors, is being drawn up to attempt to crack down on the problem of fraudulently issued plastic PRNs.

Mr Simmons said: “We are working with others in plastics industry and the government's Advisory Committee on Packaging on a protocol on plastics, which will improve the controls on plastic PRNs and add guidelines to improve the quality of PRNs. I will be raising this issue with them at the next meeting.”

Register for free to comment

Subscribe to receive our newsletters and to leave comments.

The Blog Box

Back to top

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest waste and recycling news straight to your inbox.

Subscribe
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.