The claim comes from the sector's Welsh umbrella group, Cylch. The organisation has hailed a new report, which it says comes “in stark contrast” to a recent HSE warning that using larger kerbside recycling boxes can breach health and safety guidelines (see letsrecycle.com story).
” We didn't have any pre-determined remit to look at any particular type, we just happened to have chosen schemes that mostly used boxes and bags. “
– Dr Rob Davies, CHERE
Cylch chief executive Mal Williams claimed the Centre for Health and Environmental Research and Expertise (CHERE) report “puts another nail in the coffin for those advocating co-mingled collection in wheelie bins on health and safety grounds.”
But Dr Rob Davies, one of the authors of the CHERE report, told letsrecycle.com today that there had been some confusion over the report.
Findings
The report itself found that for the nine Welsh kerbside collection schemes, the weight of boxes being collected ranged from 0.5kg to 12.0kg, while the average weight of bags varied from 0.5kg to 28kg.
The main risks found in using boxes and bags were twists and strains.
Researchers noted that video evidence demonstrated “a potentially significant risk” to health as operatives “frequently” collected several bags in each hand.
“This could result in musculo-skeletal problems,” the report warned. “This risk was generally less of a problem with boxes, although in some cases two boxes were stacked and carried. This could result in both musculo-skeletal health problems and a trip hazards.”
Vehicles
The CHERE study also warned that risks were presented by collection staff throwing bags up to 3m in the air into vehicles, climbing onto vehicles to re-distribute bags within collection containers and in the decanting of boxes into vehicles.
Road traffic risks were also highlighted by the report, which suggested collection staff using rear-loading vehicles were at risk of stepping back into the path of ongoing traffic.
Confusion
The issue of confusion over the report stems from its original remit and the interpretation of its results.
Dr Davies said the study of nine collection systems in Wales had not been undertaken to compare the use of kerbside boxes and bags with wheeled bins.
He said the report had been undertaken to assess general risks in kerbside recycling operations, as compared to a more general health and safety assessment undertaken in the past by the Health and Safety Executive.
Dr Davies explained: “The HSE showed that it is far more dangerous to work in waste and recycling than in other industries – something like 10 times greater risk. Clearly risk does exist within waste management, but in recycling the risks are nowhere near as great – mostly because vehicles are used in a different way. Our remit was to look at where there were significant risks and assess them in recycling.”
Dr Davies added: “We didn't look at wheelie bins at all – we didn't have any pre-determined remit to look at any particular type, we just happened to have chosen schemes that mostly used boxes and bags. In fairness to Cylch, they have tried to see it in a different angle.”
“Exaggeration”
Following the report, Cylch issued a statement stating that “using boxes and bags in kerbside recycling operations create no significant health and safety risks.” Mr Williams also commented that: “There now seems to be nothing particularly wrong with using boxes or bags to collect recyclables.”
| Related links: |
However, Dr Davies said today: “To say there are no risks is an exaggeration.”
The conclusion of the study did say it had failed to identify any significant risks within kerbside recycling operations using boxes and bags, but it added the proviso: “that could not be effectively managed or controlled”.
Register for free to comment