banner small

CIWM attacks Pickles over bin fine comments

CIWM attacks Pickles over bin fine comments
Secretary of State Eric Pickles previously slammed Somerset councils for imposing charges in 2011

The Chartered Institution of Wastes Management (CIWM) has accused Communities Secretary Eric Pickles of using misleading language over the removal of council bin fine powers.

Communities Secretary Eric Pickles has criticised town hall bin bullies for their use of fines to tackle improper disposal of waste
Communities Secretary Eric Pickles has criticised town hall bin bullies for their use of fines to tackle improper disposal of waste

The comments come days after the Cabinet Office launched its Draft Deregulation Bill on Monday (July 1), which seeks to remove unnecessary bureaucracy which it claims is costing the UK millions of pounds each year.

Among the measures are plans to remove powers to launch criminal sanctions against householders who repeatedly fail to present waste for collection properly. The government is proposing to amend section 46 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, which would limit the power of local authorities to fine householders.

Should the proposals become law, a waste disposal authority will only be able to issue a fine if an individuals actions has been, or is or was likely to be, detrimental to any amenities of the locality.

Common sense

Commenting on the launch of the consultation on Monday, Communities Secretary Eric Pickles said that the government was bringing back common sense by reining in town hall bin bullies.

He added: For too long barmy bin rules have allowed local authorities to slap fines on law-abiding people who make innocent mistakes.

“No-one is in favour of disproportionate fines or over-zealous enforcement, and talk of reining in the town hall bin bullies is highly provocative and unnecessary”

Chris Murphy, CIWM

Putting out your rubbish should be a simple process and it is ludicrous that we have a system where a milk carton in the wrong bin, or a wheelie bin a few inches out of place can lead to people facing bigger fines than shoplifters.

But CIWM has criticised the language used by the Mr Pickles, claiming that his comments were provocative and unnecessary.

The organisations deputy chief executive Chris Murphy said: No-one is in favour of disproportionate fines or over-zealous enforcement, and talk of reining in the town hall bin bullies is highly provocative and unnecessary. Even more so because evidence strongly suggests that most councils have used fines as a very last resort, if at all.

Disappointment

Meanwhile, Mr Murphy said that CIWM was disappointed that the government has proposed to replace the criminal offence set out in Section 46 of the 1990 Act, with a new civil sanction.

He added: In our consultation response, we said it was essential that local authorities continue to have the necessary powers to take effective action against those who persistently spoil the local environment by discarding poorly contained rubbish or, just as importantly, compromise recycling through wilful contamination. By removing the underpinning criminal offence, the draft Bill will leave councils without an appropriate recourse in cases of severe and repeated abuse.

The group has also expressed concern over a lack of clear guidance over what is deemed to be nuisance or detriment to the locality, and said that such guidance will be essential if the new regulations are to be applied consistently by councils.

Meanwhile, CIWM has commented that the plans could undermine the governments efforts to improve the quality of recyclate produced by local authorities.

Mr Murphy added: It remains unclear at this stage how serious and persistent contamination of recyclables can be addressed under the definition of nuisance or detriment to the local amenity. By seriously curtailing local authority powers to deter such behaviour, the government risks undermining the concerted effort by councils and householders in recent years to improve recycling quality and realise the maximum environmental and economic benefits.

Register for free to comment

Subscribe to receive our newsletters and to leave comments.

The Blog Box

Back to top

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest waste and recycling news straight to your inbox.

Subscribe
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.