Sweeping changes to council recycling collections because of TEEP would be excessively costly for councils and are unlikely due to budget constraints, a leading local authority waste and recycling officer has said.
Speaking at the 2014 Collections Conference on Wednesday (March 12), John Woodruff, head of waste at Bromley council and chair of the National Association of Waste Disposal Officers (NAWDO) offered his views on the effect of the revised Waste Framework Directive on local authorities.

The regulations state that separate collections of at least paper, metal, plastic and glass will be required from January 2015 where they are technically, environmentally and economically practicable (TEEP) and appropriate to meet the necessary quality standards for the relevant recycling sectors.
This has led to questions over collection systems and quality, and whether some councils will need to change their arrangements to comply with the law, or offer a robust justification of their current scheme.
According to Mr Woodruff, a wide variety of collection systems have arisen among the UKs local authorities for reasons including the availability of treatment facilities, technology available at the time a contract is let and the needs of the local population.
And, he added that councils are locked into set procurement cycles which are difficult to alter once a long-term collection contract has begun especially due to increasing financial constraints placed on them through government budget cuts.
Mr Woodruff said: By the end of 2016, local government funding from central government will have been reduced by 27%. Bromleys budget has been cut by more than 30 million and we have another 30 million of savings to find. When we have to find those kinds of savings can we really spend more money on waste?
Guidance
He went on to analyse guidance made available by the European Commission in June 2012 (see letsrecycle.com story), which stated that the test over whether a service is economically practicable refers to a separate collection which does not cause excessive costs in comparison with the treatment of a non-separated waste stream.
‘I would argue that in the current system, any additional cost is an excessive cost. If you have got no money you cant put a better scheme in.’
John Woodruff, NAWDO
Reflecting on this point, Mr Woodruff, said: I would argue that in the current system, any additional cost is an excessive cost. If you have got no money you cant put a better scheme in. We have spent too much time poring over legal definitions, when actually quality against cost is the most important issue.
Hurdles
Elsewhere, Joe Papineschi, director of Eunomia Research & Consulting claimed that councils would have to be thorough when making assessment of whether their services conform to the TEEP requirements.
He said: There are relatively high hurdles that you need to demonstrate that it is not TEEP to have separate collection. On the technical side, I think it is not straight forward to make the case that there is a significant practicability barrier to separate collection.
When you combine economic costs there may be places where it is possible that there might be places where it is possible to make that argument. There are some extreme cases but there is a widespread use of separate collection.
Related Links
Earlier in the day, delegates heard from Anna Willetts, associate at legal firm Dentons, who said that councils need to be able to provide a strong evidence base to justify any decisions taken over collection systems and TEEP (see letsrecycle.com story).
Ray Georgeson of the Resource Association reminded councils of the importance of producing high quality recyclate and said that they should question collection contractors over rebates for producing quality material (see letsrecycle.com story).
Register for free to comment